Showing posts with label smoking ban. Show all posts
Showing posts with label smoking ban. Show all posts

Monday, February 1, 2010

50% less smokers equals 76,000 less police officers

The Government has today announced plans to halve the number of smokers in the UK population, reducing the percentage of smokers from 21% to 10% by 2020. A laudable aim, smoking is a terrible habit that affects the health of those that do it and those around it, however one of the main drivers for this is said to be reducing the cost of smokers to the NHS.

The idea that we should cut the number of smokers on the basis of economics is I’m afraid a seriously flawed one. Let’s take a look at the numbers.

In 2007 - 2008 (the last year full figures were available for) the Revenue’s excise take on tobacco products was £8.1 billion with a VAT take of £1.8 billion leading to a total of £10bn a year in revenue. (Estimates for 08-09 put the figure even higher at around £10.7bn.)

So in an admittedly  simplistic argument if we halve the number of smokers then we halve that revenue (although in reality most of it will come from the hardened smokers who won’t quit but lets go with it anyway) so the government would only receive £5bn in a year rather than £10bn.

On the other side treating smoking related diseases costs the NHS £2.7bn a year, so if we halve the number of smokers we can expect a saving of approximately half or £1.35bn.

Subtracting the saving from the lost revenue we see that by cutting the number of smokers in half the government is down by £3.65bn a year or the equivalent of around seventy six thousand police officers a year (at £48,000 a year based on Home Office numbers).

Now I don't disagree that cutting smoking numbers is a good idea, a very good idea in fact, but the effect of this will mean that as well as trying to cut public spending because of the deficit over the next 10 years we’ll also be needing to save £3.65bn a year, or just disband the police force.

Related Content